From Change Management to Renewal Capability: Why Traditional Approaches Fall Short

Author:
Elina Ali-Melkkilä
March 5, 2025
Read Time:
10
minutes

In my years working with organisations navigating transformation, I've witnessed a consistent pattern. Companies invest significant resources in change management initiatives yet find themselves repeatedly facing the same challenges. Projects launch with enthusiasm, processes get documented, training sessions occur—and then the organisation slides back into familiar patterns. The transformation either stalls or requires continuous external support to maintain momentum.

This isn't simply poor execution. It reflects a fundamental limitation in how we've approached organisational change.

The Problem with Episodic Change

Traditional change management treats transformation as a series of distinct episodes. We implement a new system, restructure a department, or roll out a strategic initiative using project management approaches. Each change is managed as a discrete event with a beginning, middle, and end. When it's "complete," we move on to the next initiative.

But in today's business landscape, change isn't episodic—it's continuous. Market disruptions, technological evolution, sustainability imperatives, and workforce expectations create a constant need for adaptation. When we treat each change as separate from the ongoing life of the organisation, we miss the opportunity to build something more valuable: the capability to renew continuously.

Think about your own organisation. How much time passes between major change initiatives? For most, the answer is "increasingly little." The pause between significant transformations has shortened dramatically, yet our approach hasn't evolved to match this reality.

Where Traditional Approaches Miss the Mark

Focus on Compliance Rather Than Capability

Many change methodologies emphasise getting people to comply with new processes or adopt new tools. Success gets measured by implementation metrics—how many employees completed training, whether deadlines were met, if the system launched on schedule.

This focus on compliance creates a fundamental disconnect. People may follow new procedures without developing the understanding or capability to adapt those procedures as conditions evolve. When the next change arrives (as it inevitably will), the organisation faces the same learning curve and resistance all over again.

Separation of Strategy from Implementation

Another limitation emerges from how we separate strategic direction from practical implementation. Leadership teams develop transformation visions that then get translated into execution plans by different groups. This division creates gaps where meaning and purpose get lost in translation.

I recently worked with a technology company whose strategic pivot toward customer-centric solutions was struggling despite significant investment. The disconnect wasn't in the strategy or the implementation teams' capabilities—it was in the bridges between them. The strategic vision hadn't created meaningful connections to daily work, leaving teams implementing processes without understanding how they created customer value.

Lack of Reflective Learning Cycles

Perhaps most critically, traditional approaches rarely build in structured reflection that transforms experiences into organisational learning. Without these reflective cycles, valuable insights remain isolated with individuals rather than becoming institutional knowledge that enhances adaptation capability.

When we fail to build these reflective practices, each change initiative becomes an isolated experiment rather than a building block in ongoing development. The organisation doesn't get better at change—it simply experiences more of it.

The Shift to Renewal Capability

Renewal capability represents a fundamental shift in how we approach organisational transformation. Rather than managing change events, we build the organisation's ongoing ability to adapt, learn, and transform continuously.

This capability operates at three interconnected levels:

  1. Company direction – Clarity about strategic purpose and how it translates into priorities
  2. Team dynamics – Collaborative approaches that connect strategy to implementation
  3. Individual growth – Personal capacity for adaptation and contribution to collective renewal

When these levels align and reinforce each other, transformation shifts from something that happens to the organisation to something that happens through it as part of its natural evolution.

Building Bridges Instead of Barriers

The journey toward renewal capability begins with dialogue that builds shared understanding across organisational levels. This isn't simply communication—it's the intentional creation of spaces where different perspectives can engage meaningfully with strategic challenges.

A manufacturing client struggling with sustainability transformation illustrates this approach. Rather than cascading change messages downward, we established dialogue forums connecting leadership strategic vision directly with implementation teams. These conversations revealed critical insights about operational realities that reshaped the transformation approach, creating ownership at all levels rather than compliance with top-down directives.

These dialogue spaces serve as bridges, connecting:

  • Strategic intention with implementation reality
  • Leadership vision with frontline experience
  • Current capabilities with future requirements

Beyond these dialogue bridges, renewal capability requires establishing reflective learning practices that transform experiences into organizational wisdom. These structured reflection cycles shift the focus from "Did we implement it?" to "What did we learn, and how does that shape our next steps?"

Measuring Transformation Differently

Building renewal capability also means evolving how we measure success. Traditional metrics focus on activity—deadlines met, features implemented, training sessions conducted. While these measurements matter, they don't capture the development of adaptation capability.

More meaningful indicators of renewal capability include:

  • How quickly teams can recognise and respond to changing conditions
  • The quality of dialogue across organisational boundaries
  • The degree to which reflective practices have become embedded in work routines
  • Evidence that teams are applying learning from previous transformations to current challenges

These indicators focus on capabilities rather than activities, providing insight into whether the organisation is becoming more adaptable rather than simply implementing more changes.

Beginning Your Renewal Journey

The path toward renewal capability isn't a standardised methodology but a journey shaped by your organisational context. However, several starting points consistently create momentum:

Establish dialogue across organisational boundaries

Create intentional spaces where strategy connects directly with implementation through meaningful conversation. These aren't merely information sessions but opportunities for collective sense-making that builds shared understanding.

Implement reflection cycles

Build regular pauses for learning into your transformation initiatives. These structured reflections transform experiences into capabilities by explicitly identifying insights and their implications for future adaptation.

Map the connections between levels

Examine how company direction translates into team priorities and individual growth opportunities. Where are the gaps that interrupt this flow? Where are the bridges that facilitate it?

Identify early indicators of renewal

What would demonstrate that your organisation's adaptation capability is strengthening? Look for evidence in how teams approach challenges, whether they're establishing their own reflective practices, and how they're connecting their work to broader strategic direction.

The Competitive Advantage of Renewal

In today's rapidly evolving business landscape, renewal isn't optional—it's essential. Organisations that develop the capability to adapt continuously create a distinct competitive advantage that competitors struggle to replicate.

This advantage appears in:

  • Faster response to market changes
  • More effective implementation of strategic initiatives
  • Reduced friction and resistance during transformations
  • Enhanced capacity to integrate external perspectives
  • Greater resilience during disruption

Most importantly, renewal capability transforms how your organisation experiences change—from a series of disruptive events to a natural rhythm of continuous evolution.

The question isn't whether your organisation will face transformation. The question is whether you'll build the capability to navigate it successfully and continuously. The journey from change management to renewal capability doesn't simply improve how you implement individual initiatives—it fundamentally transforms how your organisation evolves in a constantly changing world.

About The Author

Elina Ali-Melkkilä is the founder and CEO of Direo, a Finnish consultancy helping organisations build renewal capability through dialogue, reflection, and learning. Learn more about Direo's approach to sustainable transformation.

Reflections on Sustainable Growth

Resources for Change Leaders Building Sustainable Growth

Explore how I drive sustainable growth through strategic change management.

Read more
Build the Bridge to Sustainable Growth

My mission is to strengthen organisational resilience through dialogue, reflection, and learning—creating the conditions where companies transform their approach to change into pathways for sustainable growth.

Get in touch